Review: Hong Kong Ballet's Lady of the Camellias
Hong Kong Ballet premiered last weekend a new production of Lady of the Camellias, originally choreographed in 1994 by American choreographer Val Caniparoli. Based on Alexandre Dumas’ novel of the same name and set to a score by Chopin, this three-act ballet tells the tragic story of the courtesan Marguerite and her lover Armand. This premiere is timely, since it’s over a decade since local audiences last saw John Neumeier’s famous version of the ballet performed by the Hamburg Ballet at the Hong Kong Arts Festival.In the Caniparoli production, the narrative is pretty straightforward and the action is easy to follow. Act 1 starts with Marguerite’s chance meeting with Armand and ends with their bedroom duet. Act 2 opens with a party in a country garden in the summer, before Marguerte is visited by Armand’s father, who forces her to leave his son. Act 3 ends with a melodramatic solo by Marguerite before her death.
Caniparoli’s choreography is too basic. There are not enough variations in the steps. In the duets, for instance, the big soaring overhead lifts occur too frequently – after a while, the routines become predictable and dull. The ensemble dances are also repetitive, and the duets soupy. That said, the final pas de deux towards the end of Act 3 for Marguerite and Armand is quite moving. And the group dance in Act 2 provides some exciting solos for the male soloists, particularly Li Lin and Shen Jie.
The scheme of Caniparoli’s choreography is somewhat formulaic, leaving