The Infinite Wrench
Photograph: Courtesy New York Neo-Futurists | The Infinite Wrench
Photograph: Courtesy New York Neo-Futurists

Off-Off Broadway shows in NYC

Looking for the best Off-Off Broadway shows? Here are the most promising productions at NYC’s smaller venues this month.

Adam Feldman
Advertising

Broadway and Off Broadway productions get most of the attention, but to get a true sense of the range and diversity of New York theater, you need to look to the smaller productions collectively known as Off-Off Broadway. There are more than dozens of Off-Off Broadway spaces in New York, mostly with fewer than 99 seats. Experimental plays thrive in New York's best Off-Off Broadway venues; that's where you'll find many of the city's most challenging and original works. But Off-Off is more than just the weird stuff: It also includes everything from original dramas to revivals of rarely seen classics, and it's a good place to get early looks at rising talents. What's more, it tends to be affordable; while cheap Broadway tickets can be hard to find, most Off-Off Broadway shows are in the $15–$35 range. Here are some of the current shows that hold the most promise.

RECOMMENDED: Full guide to Off Broadway shows in NYC 

Off-Off Broadway shows in NYC

  • East Village
  • price 2 of 4
Frigid New York gives you the chills in its fourth annual festival inspired by Mexico's dead-lifting Día de los Muertos. The lineup features spooky variety shows, short horror plays, Edgar Allan Poe works, a traditional ofrenda, psychic mediums, a tiny interactive matchbox theatre, a murder ballad musical, necromancer burlesque, and other tales of the macabre. Among them are Stephen Smith's One Man Poe, Andrew Agress's The Witching Hour and Maeve Aurora Chapman and Liam Corley's Death Owns an Ice Cream Parlor. Visit the festival's website for a schedule and a full list of offerings for shows.
  • Comedy
  • DUMBO
  • price 1 of 4
Thy favorite scary movie, oh, what is't? Brooklyn’s Random Access Theatre’s boozy-geeky Drunk Texts series muddles classical texts—or modern ones reimagined as classical—into a cocktail of drinking games, improv and audience interaction, in which the audiences chooses which thespians take shots. Now the gang returns for Halloween with Thou Wilt Scream, Robert Price's mock-Shakespearean gloss on horror flicks. 
Advertising
  • Comedy
  • Williamsburg
  • Open run
  • price 1 of 4
After more than a decade performing Too Much Light Makes the Baby Go Blind, an ever-changing collection of 30 two-minutes plays, the New York Neo-Futurists had to change course when piece's author pulled the rights abruptly in 2016. Now the troupe performs a different ever-changing collection of 30 two-minute plays called The Infinite Wrench. (We wrote about it here.) In 2025, the troupe moved from Manhattan to the recently established Williamsburg outpost of Chicago's legendary Second City improv-comedy factory.
  • Musicals
  • Midtown West
  • price 2 of 4
The ghost of an axe-murdered girl haunts a New Orleans mansion—and must confront her own terrors before it's too late—in David P. Johnson's original musical, which mixes gothic horror with dark comedy. Johnson and Arden Teresa Lewis co-direct a cast of six led by Helen Floersh as the cute little spook who is trying to bury the hatchet.
Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Hell's Kitchen
  • price 2 of 4
Jenny Lee Stern plays washed-up old hag Elisabeth Sparkle and Jayke Workman is her gorgeous young alter ego in an irreverent musical spoof of the 2024 Hollywood body-horror hit The Substance, with a score that repurposes (and perhaps rejuvenates?) songs from the Broadway catalog. Sam LaFrage directs a cast that includes Jaime Lyn Beatty—who co-wrote the show with Jonathan Hogue and Singfeld auteur Billy Recce—as well as Garrett Poladian, Megan Griggs and Gabriella Joy Rodriguez, plus TikTok's Julian Sewell as perennial Oscars bridesmaid Paloma Dimond. 
Advertising
  • Drama
  • Hell's Kitchen
  • price 2 of 4
John DeSotelle directs a double feature of atmospheric one-acts adapted from a pair of 1843 short stories by horror master Edgar Allan Poe. Both stories—"The Black Cat" and "The Tell-Tale Heart"—deal with violence, guilt, madness and bodies that just won't stay hidden. Jake Lesh and Dan Yaiullo lead the cast.
  • Drama
  • Hell's Kitchen
  • price 1 of 4
Playwright-performer Patricia Lynn (The Maid and the Mesmerizer) sinks her teeth into the legend of Dracula in a feminist modern-day memory play. Jacob Titus directs the world premiere, whose cast of four includes Mark Weatherup Jr. and Lynn herself as John and Millie Harker, Miles Purinton as Van Helsing and David Israeli as the batty Count. Proceeds from the October 29 performance benefit the New York Blood Center. 

More theater stories

Advertising
Recommended
    You may also like
    You may also like
    Advertising