The Mai Mai Mai cocktail at Lobby Bar SF
Photograph: Courtesy Lobby Bar SF
Photograph: Courtesy Lobby Bar SF

Embrace the season with these winter rum cocktails in San Francisco

The rum-based cocktails currently on the menu at San Francisco bars will either play into your desire to hibernate — or transport you to a faraway beach

Clara Hogan
Advertising

Winter in San Fransisco may not be as brutal as much of the country, but the days are still shorter, darker, and chillier. And this moody season calls for a strong drink.

Many of the restaurants and bars in the city adapt the ingredients highlighted on their menus based on what's available at the local Farmers' Markets, or simply what pairs well with the seasonal vibe. This winter, that means certain citrus fruits, chocolate, chai, or really anything that pairs well with cold-weather dishes. When it comes to cocktails, bar directors are leaning on rum-based drinks with various spices, herbs, and liqueurs that will keep you feeling cozy all the way through spring.

We caught up with some of the best bars in San Francisco to hear about their best rum-based winter libations. You'll find a twist on the espresso martini, spiced-packed cocktails, and tropical drinks that will make you feel like you're on a beach somewhere warmer.

Best rum winter cocktails in San Francisco

This cozy yet elegant bar is new to the Castro, and it's already winning hearts. The bar just added a new cocktail heading into the winter months: the Mai Mai Mai, which is essentially a fun take on the classic Mai Tai. The primary flavor is a savory, bitter-sweet Kumquat-Pop liqueur from local California citrus apéritif company, Mommenpop, complimented by rum and pineapple juice. It's refreshing, savory, and even chuggable — so be careful. The warming spices garnished on top pair perfectly with this Winter tiki-inspired cocktail.

Finding your way to Bar Nonnina is part of the fun. Step inside Fiorella, a modern Italian spot in the Inner Sunset, and you'll be greeted with a welcome cocktail as the host walks you upstairs, past the rooftop bar, into this intimate space. Bar Director Dan Burns crafts an impressive cocktail menu incorporating seasonal ingredients and isn't afraid to be playful. This winter, he's debuting the Chaianna, a hyper-local drink full of warm spicy holiday notes. The cocktail pairs Oakland's Wright & Brown rum – full of caramel, oak and vanilla notes – and Chico Chai’s original chai recipe. On top, a heavy whip infused with Brucato's "Orchards" amaro, gives it more nuttiness, cinnamon and orchard fruit notes. "We think you should drink it in front of our fireplace on a really cold day," Burns says.

Advertising
Kaiyo is a darling of the restaurant- and bar-packed Cow Hollow neighborhood. It's also one of the best places in the city for bright, unique cocktails paired with nikkei-style cooking. The "Prince of the Sun" cocktail on the menu aims to be nikkei-style mojito — bartenders swap sugar for white miso syrup, shake with pisco, agricole rum, and top it off with yuzu and lime soda instead of seltzer. The result is a refreshing winter cocktail that will make you feel like you're on a faraway beach.

Step back in time into the historic, art deco-inspired Redwood Room inside the Clift Royal Sonesta Hotel, which has been a go-to spot for sipping cocktails since it opened the day after prohibition was repealed. Warm up among walls paneled in redwood and order the Velveteen Dream, a more complex take on a classic espresso martini. Bartenders replace vodka with a cacao-infused rum, paired with Mr. Black Coffee liqueur, vermouth, and a unique combination of bitters to offset the sweetness. The drink is served over one large ice cube, making it all too easy to tilt back.

Advertising

If the name of this cocktail intrigues you, run don't walk to Members Only, a new two-story bar and restaurant in Lower Nob Hill. Don't let the name stop you – it's supposed to be satirical. This playful and rich drink includes a donut-washed rum mixed with cold brew, NOLA liqueur, cream de cacao, as well as cinnamon and chocolate bitters. “It tastes like dunking a chocolate glazed donut into a cup of fresh coffee,” Jae says Bar Director Candice Jae.

Ernest Hemingway forever changed the history of the daiquiri, so the story goes, by asking a bartender to make a double daiquiri with no sugar. The bartender replaced the sugar with floral marasca cherry pit liqueur and a bit of grapefruit, creating what's now known as the "Hemingway Daiquiri." At the Cavalier downtown SF, their take uses a Nicaraguan-aged rum with a dash of cachaca (sugar grass distillate) from Brazil for structure and vegetal character. The result: the Papa Doble, which you can sip all winter long at this London-inspired brasserie, located next to Hotel Zetta.

Advertising
If you're looking to get away from reality, look no further than Last Rites, a bar in Duboce Triangle with a back bar actually built from an actual airplane fuselage — and bar stools made from airplane seats. This is a rum bar through and through, with more than 150 options on the menu. This winter we recommend C.R.E.A.M., made with rum cream, brandy, pineapple-spiced rum, charred pineapple whiskey, vanilla milk, raw sugar, and egg. The result is a drink that's rich, complex, yet not too sweet — it's everything you hope from eggnog, with tropical dessert fruit speckled in.

The iconic Tonga Room in Fairmont Hotel is an institution in San Francisco — and you'll find delicious rum cocktails here all year long. One in particular to give a whirl this winter is the "Hurry Kane," an ode to their namesake bar and Tiki god who "protects all who gather here." The drink mixes Barbadian and Overproof rums with cognac, lemon, passion fruit and port. 

Advertising
The Snug, located in Pacific Heights, consistently has a coconut daiquiri on its menu, but the bar team alters the recipe for the time of year. In the fall and winter, they transition to the spiced version of the cocktail — they split the base into equal parts Jamaican Gold Rum and Spiced Rum, and then fat wash it with coconut oil, straining and bottling for service.

Situated in the Van Ness corridor, the Madrigal is a favorite local spot for artisan cocktails and shareable plates. The cocktail menu is constantly rotating based on season, and this winter, the Pliny's Potion offers diners a rum-based drink that infused with fig cordial, Nocino – a sweet and slightly bitter Italian liqueur made with unripe walnuts – Oloroso sherry, and Blackstrap bitters.

Advertising
Located on Polk Street in Russian Hill, the Macondray is a favorite neighborhood bar serving natural wine, local beer, and stellar craft cocktails. Stop in now for the Lemon Bomb, made with butter-washed Santa Theresa Rum, lemon juice, simple syrup, and egg. Tilt this one back and enjoy with some of the bar's staples, oysters or lobster rolls.
This Outer Sunset bar is a favorite of the neighborhood locals –  and has gained a reputation for such impressive cocktails, it's even turned into a destination those traveling from outside of the immediate area. This winter, try the Parkside Punch, a fruit-forward rum punch. The drink is full of bright notes including guava, strawberry, and orange, while the distinct taste of li hing mui (made from dried salted plums) brings it all together.
Recommended
    You may also like
    You may also like
    Advertising