new york airbnbs
Airbnb
Airbnb

The best Airbnbs near NYC with amazing fireplaces

Get cozy in front of these massive fireplaces not far from the city

Shaye Weaver
Advertising

There's a chill in the air and the thought of cuddling up in front of a roaring fire is, frankly, irresistible. Even better, add a lake view or mountain range to the equation and you're really onto a winner. You don't even need to venture that far from bustling New York City to get it. We've picked out some of the most impressive fireplaces to spend an evening in front of at the coziest, most charming Airbnbs near NYC. Once you settle in and start to unwind, you'll never want to leave. Mmm toasty.

Updated October 2024: Need more choice? We got you. Check out our two new properties that range from super rustic to luxury lakeside cabins – both ideal for romantic getaways. 

RECOMMENDED:
The coziest Airbnbs you can rent near NYC this winter
The best Airbnbs with fireplaces in NYC

Who makes the cut? While we might not stay in every Airbnb featured, we've based our list on top reviews, hosts, and amenities to find you the best stays. This article includes affiliate links. These links have no influence on our editorial content. For more information, see our affiliate guidelines.

Airbnbs near NYC with cozy fireplaces

1. The lakefront home by a private island in New Jersey

This impressive property is a sight for sore eyes – inside and out. It's connected by a wooden bridge to a private island that's yours to explore. The lush forest and lake views surrounding the house leave you fully immersed in nature. While you're not gazing out across the expanse from the floor-to-ceiling windows, there are many welcomed distractions to be found inside; from the huge sink-in sofa by the fire place to the cute kitchen and woodland-themed bedrooms, there are plenty of places to find some inner peace with a book in hand or just your thoughts to focus on. And if you didn't think it could get any better, there's a idyllic patio and fire pit for outdoor socializing. 

Rooms? Two. Sleeps six guests. 
Mood? Boujee woodland hideaway. 
Location perks? In Highland Lakes, in a private community on top of a mountain. 
Budget range? A good chunk of cash, but for a vacation you won't forget. 

2. The tiny bungalow cottage in Hastings-on-Hudson

This imperfectly perfect cottage makes for a charming romantic getaway for couples that prefer quirks over quality. Cozy up among the colorful furniture, eclectic art and cute fire place, or take to the outdoors for a patio BBQ or a swing in the hammock. 

Rooms? One. Sleeps two guests. 
Mood? Eclectic cottage core. 
Location perks? In a quiet suburban neighborhood 35 minutes outside of NYC. A few blocks to the Hudson River. 
Budget range? An affordable option. 

Advertising

3. The lakefront cabin in Middle Island

While it's not in the wilderness, this Long Island studio cabin is a secluded retreat on Pine Lake, where you can chill on a deck or go inside and stay warm by an impressive fireplace enclosed by glass. It's a great headquarters for those who want to venture out to nearby Wildwood State Park, a number of wineries and more. It sleeps four guests, so gather your closest pals and head off on a calming trip away.

Rooms? One. Sleeps four guests.
Mood? Log cabin vibes.
Location perks? Brookhaven Ecology Site and Animal Preserve is a short drive, as is the sandy Cedar Beach.
Budget range? Mid-range.

4. The secluded cabin in the woods of Milford

Ideal for a couple's getaway – even in the height of winter – this adorable log cabin in the forest is all things rustic. Featuring a stone fireplace as its centerpiece, this Airbnb is just 90 minutes from NYC and has everything you need to get comfy and cozy real fast. The interiors showcase knotty pine throughout, while the kitchenette has the basics to ensure you can enjoy a hot cuppa joe while you sit by the fire. Outside there's an elevated wooden deck with two Adirondack chairs in which to lay back and soak up the forest.

Rooms? One. Sleeps two guests.
Mood? Rustic.
Location perks? Nearby, there's a stream leading into a private lake in which you can swim (perhaps in the warmer months).
Budget range? Mid- to high-end.

Advertising

5. The rustic log cabin with mountain views in Phoenicia

This log cabin is all about rustic living, with wooden beds and cozy quilts to complete the vibe. The three-bed has a big roaring fireplace that you can read beside or gaze into as you take in the sounds of the trickling Woodland Valley creek. It's a quaint stay for those looking for the serenity of the mountains in a bucolic setting.

Rooms? Three. Sleeps four guests.
Mood? Twee cabin in the woods.
Location perks? Take in a beautiful hike with 25-mile views or go fishing in the Esopus River a mile away.
Budget range? Affordable.

6. The CubHouse in Bearsville

It's a wood-burning fireplace you'll find in this 1909 cub house. Originally owned by a 'medicine woman', the one-bedroom home has a fairytale-like feel that starts with the grand stone fireplace and continues up to a loft-style bedroom and beautiful kitchen with a stone wall and arched doorway. And when you want to just take it all in, there's a hanging egg chair you can lounge in, soundtracked by a babbling brook.

Rooms? One. Sleeps two guests.
Mood? Dreamy cottage.
Location perks? You'll have access to the surrounding forest and river with views of the mountains.
Budget range? Mid-range.

Advertising

7. The Windy Top Cottage in Granby

This old building built in 1932 was a cottage for the domestic staff of the family of H.L. Bitter. It looks like something out of a fairytale with its stone facade, fireplace and shabby chic interior. It's been renovated, but still has the original bath fixtures from the ’30s and a coffee service area with a 1935 Fridgidaire refrigerator filled with cold drinks. The bedrooms are spacious but cozy and have windows with quaint flower boxes that overlook a herb and flower garden.

Rooms? Two. Sleeps four guests.
Mood? English country cottage.
Location perks? Fresh mountain air, which is best enjoyed beside the firepit.
Budget range? Cheap and cheerful.

8. The little red cabin in Andover

Looking to get away for a while? Or need an affordable writers' retreat? Consider this long-let cabin near Tomahawk Lake. Available for 28 days at a time, it's ana bsolute steal for an extended stay. Unwind by the stone fireplace and take inspiration from the surrounding woodland and lake. The house is simple but quiet and offers the perfect respite with vaulted ceilings, wood paneling and a loft sleeping space. There's also an outdoor firepit for nighttime s'mores.

Rooms? Two. Sleeps four guests.
Mood? Charming bolthole.
Location perks? Restaurants and shopping are nearby and the cabin is only a five-minute walk to the beach club and trails.
Budget range? Super cheap daily rate.

Advertising

9. The Black Bear Ridge in Fleischmanns

Nestled between the woods and a meadow on a five-acre property, this four-bedroom cabin has a stone, wood-burning fireplace to play games beside and cozy up to in the colder months. Each room looks comfortable, but the master has a large balcony, perfect for sipping your morning coffee or star-gazing. You can explore its three acres of woods or venture further out into the Catskill Mountains nearby or go skiing at the Belleayre Ski Center in the winter. Plus, the home is only 20 minutes from the Phoenicia Diner and Esopus Creek.

Rooms? Four. Sleeps eight guests.
Mood? Idyllic charm.
Location perks? Skiing options aplenty.
Budget range? Bit of a splurge.

10. The cozy creekside cabin in the Catskills

Just five minutes from Phoenicia, this cabin has a beautiful stone fireplace that you can cozy up in front of while taking in views of the surrounding woods. The Airbnb itself is located on a 0.75-acre piece of land next to Stony Clove Creek and it's packed with blankets, cushions and rugs that'll make your stay even cozier. Plus, for that extra twee factor, the kitchen is fully equipped for all your baking (and cooking) needs.

Rooms? Two. Sleeps four guests.
Mood? Modern woodland escape.
Location perks? Hiking is readily available to the adventurous.
Budget range? Very affordable.

Airbnb stays near NYC

  • Travel

A winter getaway isn't complete without a gorgeous, snowy landscape.

Being snowed in inside a cozy cabin or chic ski chalet is the ultimate winter activity and Airbnb has plenty of stays to choose from that have beautiful snowy views.

We rounded up nine cabins, chalets and stays that'll have you gazing out at the peaceful snowy blanket before you in no time.

RECOMMENDED: 10 Stunning Airbnbs for Ski Getaways From NYC

  • Hotels

Looking for a romantic getaway this Valentine's Day? Airbnb has a slew of options for cozy stays with lush views, incredible fireplaces, and relaxing amenities that are in high demand after a long year of quarantining in our tiny apartments.

Let's face it. Flowers and chocolate may not cut it this year. Time away with your loved one might be the only romantic gesture that speaks loud enough these days. Therefore, we've selected nine amazingly romantic Airbnb stays that easily convey "I love you" or at least "Let's be together."

RECOMMENDED: Valentine’s Day in NYC guide

Advertising
  • Travel

Whether you're a New Yorker craving a change of scenery or planning a trip to NYC, we think it's high time that you tried something a bit different. Thankfully, Airbnb is packed with unique accommodation options, with hosts who are usually more than willing to offer suggestions on great things to do in the neighborhood. And in these uncertain times, Airbnb hosts have gone above and beyond with new cleaning protocols and safety precautions. 

RECOMMENDED: The best Airbnb New York City rentals

This article includes affiliate links. These links have no influence on our editorial content. For more information, click here.

  • Hotels

Want to stay cozy as f*ck during your trip to New York? Rent one of these Airbnbs with fireplaces instead of a boring old hotel room. Whether you want to stay in one of the coolest Airbnb Brooklyn rentals or you’re looking for something near all the top New York attractions, this list includes plenty of suitable options. Fireplaces add pizzazz to modern lofts, vintage brownstones and artsy studios—and the ambiance that flickering flames lend to a chilly evening is hard to deny. Fair warning: Once you’ve seen how stunning these Airbnbs with fireplaces in NYC look, you might not be willing to go back to the typical Airbnb New York City rental.

RECOMMENDED: Full guide to the best hotels in NYC

Advertising
  • Travel

The best winter getaways from NYC all have a few things in common: Charming aesthetics, snug blankets, steaming cups of hot chocolate and oodles of snow. These remarkable Airbnbs at ski resorts near NYC check all the boxes. Whether you’d like to book an effortless weekend trip within easy reach of the city or want to go the whole hog and take a full week out on the slopes, there are loads of cabins near NYC to rent on Airbnb. Beautiful chalets, contemporary condos and nineteenth-century farmhouses all appear on our list of Airbnbs near the slopes. Don’t forget your gloves!

Note: please check the latest travel guidance before booking your trip

RECOMMENDED: Find more weekend getaways from NYC

  • Travel

If you haven't been in a treehouse since you were a kid, you've been missing out. Now is the time to rekindle your love for living aloft in the woods by renting a treehouse Airbnb, especially as the leaves change. There's nothing cozier and more fantastical than taking in nature's beauty from the air. It's a step up from camping near NYC and offers a way to have the secluded getaway that you've been needing. Make sure to pack your hiking boots and essentials! Some of these are quite off-the-grid.

RECOMMENDED: 13 cozy cabins near NYC that you can rent on Airbnb

Recommended
    More on Airbnb
      You may also like
      You may also like
      Advertising