On October 22, New York City’s beloved Angel of Music will sing once more. The Phantom of the Opera, the record-breaking, longest running show in Broadway history, returns to the famed Majestic Theatre, home to (arguably) the most famous chandelier in the world. As timeless as Times Square itself, the Olivier- and Tony Award-winning sensation from the mind of Andrew Lloyd Webber – directed by Harold Prince with choreography by Gillian Lynne – has captivated New Yorkers with its sweet intoxication since its 1988 opening. It’s indisputable, then, that Phantom’s long-anticipated return can only mean one thing: New York, not just Broadway, is back.
So to celebrate, we’re taking a page out of the Phantom’s book and diving underground to explore the hidden underbelly of NYC in style. From fashionable cocktails to chilling crypt tours, these five underfoot dwellings may leave you, like our masked friend, feeling sinfully subterrestrial.
Midtown Manhattan
Hidden beneath the luxury Bryant Park Hotel lies this chic Moroccan oasis. Just steps away from Broadway, Célon is the perfect scene for pre-show drinks or an after-show rendezvous with New York’s high society. With a rotating setlist of some of the most in-demand DJs from around the globe, you’ll certainly find your music of the night here.
Nolita
It’s been rumored that deep beneath the Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral dwell the spirits of those faithfully departed since 1809… but could you muster the courage to explore these historic crypts on a 90-minute candlelight tour? Careful where you lurk. You never know around which corner a spirit, or a phantom, may appear.
Meatpacking District
What’s better than one chandelier? Answer: Two gothic-inspired chandeliers, fit to make even the Phantom envious. The Electric Room—an intimate, subterranean lounge inconspicuously located at the end of a Meatpacking District loading ramp—welcomes fanatics of all walks of nightlife. Come for the high-end cocktails, stay for the late-night dancing, and flirt with the point of no return.
Civic Center
The original departure point for New York City’s first-ever subway ride, the now-abandoned Old City Hall Station stands untouched as a testament to the once-exquisite underground designs of 1904. The station’s vaulted tile ceilings, chandeliers, and leaded skylights can now be seen in person during an official New York Transit Museum walking tour. Tickets cost $50 and always sell out.
Brooklyn Heights
Concealed within Brooklyn’s historic Atlantic Avenue railroad tunnel awaits the gilded Le Boudoir speakeasy. Older than the Paris Opera House, the walls of this craft cocktail bar have stood since 1844 and today feature Rococo-inspired designs reminiscent of Marie Antoniette’s private chambers. Keep your hand at the level of your eye, because this is an evening worth losing your head over.