The Little Shoe Store (CLOSED)

Thanks to its growing popularity, this temporary shop for women’s footwear in sizes 3 to 5.5 is getting a permanent storefront in July (the address has yet to be determined). Until then, this tiny space operates on the weekends or during the week by appointment only (e-mail sydney@thelittleshoestore.com), but it’s well worth the extra effort. Owner Sydney Pringle curates the selection of both new and vintage styles, including Restricted platform wedges ($70), All Black woven newspaper flats ($110) and a pair of ’90s Michael Kors slouchy suede boots ($150). The shop is the exclusive NYC retailer of trendy small-size shoe brand the Odd Slipper, allowing you to scoop up its pointed-toe pumps ($130) and caged booties ($114).