Stieber's Sweet Shoppe

This new candy bar may give Dylan’s a run for its money. Step in the Greenwich Village sweet spot, which smells of freshly baked fudge ($18 per pound) and salivate over 250 types of gummies featuring unexpected flavors like spicy red hot chilli pepper (for the brave). There are more than 400 options of bulk candy here, but die-hard cocoa fans can fill their own box with chocolate-covered Oreos and pretzels to oblige a demanding sweet tooth ($8–$20).