Archangel Antiques (CLOSED)

It may look like a pre-spring-cleaning garage, stuffed with old floral rugs and glass cabinets, but this shop has the best collection of vintage buttons ($1–$100) and cufflinks (starting at $45, dating back to the 19th century) in the city. And if the hundreds of accessories to choose from are too overwhelming, the staff is more than happy to point you in the right direction. Keep your eyes peeled for delicate gold necklaces inside the jewelry cabinet and random vintage collectibles, including typewriters and home furnishings.