a couple walking in central park during the fall
Photograph: Shutterstock
Photograph: Shutterstock

The best fall date ideas in NYC

Star in your own autumn romcom while leaf peeping, day drinking and cuddling up for a scary movie.

Rossilynne Skena Culgan
Contributor: Jennifer Picht
Advertising

The leaves in Central Park are changing. You’re wearing a cozy sweater. Your latte is—finally!—pumpkin-spiced. You know what that means? It’s the perfect time to fall in love. When autumn in NYC has you feeling like Harry and/or Sally, we’ve got you covered with the very best fall date ideas. 

Woo your boo while you take in the fall foliage, cuddle up for spooky season and toast to new (or enduring) love with a cocktail. Whether it’s your first date or your 901st date, we’re here to help you make this fall feel even more romantic

RECOMMENDED: Full guide to the best things to do in the fall in NYC

Best fall date ideas in NYC

  • Things to do
  • Events & Festivals

New York has some of the very best movie theaters, but there’s just something so romantic about watching a movie under the stars.

This fall, Rooftop Cinema Club is showing classic Halloween films including Hocus Pocus, Friday the 13th, Mean Girls, The Shining, Beetlejuice, Death Becomes Her, Halloweentown, Practical Magic, American Psycho, The Nightmare Before Christmas, Halloween, Scream, and more.

Snack on popcorn and your favorite candy while you feel the fall chill run up your spine. (Bonus points if you offer your sweater.)

  • Things to do
  • Events & Festivals

After the sun goes down, the Bronx Zoo will light up this fall with more than 5,000 animal-themed jack-o’-lanterns in incredible displays. Expect to see intricately carved jack-o'-lanterns set up in different animal ecosystem scenes, such as the Amazon rainforest, Himalayas, Congo, bioluminescent deep-sea, an African Savanna waterhole and many more.

Stroll hand-in-hand with your sweetie you admire the incredible artistry.

Advertising

Celebrating a special occasion or anniversary this autumn? A sunset sail aboard Classic Harbor Line's Schooner Adirondack fits the bill for a romantic evening on the water. The gorgeous 80-foot schooner will take you away from the noise of the city, so you can admire all the stunning fall foliage before the sky turns pitch black. You can even bring your own snacks aboard!

The bright city lights will welcome you home after a night of conversing and sipping complimentary champagne with your date.

  • Things to do
  • Events & Festivals

Is your date the kind who's always listening to true crime podcasts? Then you've got to take them to the "Sinister Secrets of the Seaport" walking tour. It whisks visitors back in time for a 90-minute walking tour full of true crime tales about theft, organized crime, murder and even pirates.

Tours are available for $40/adult. Whether you're a true crime buff or you're just always in the Halloween spirit, these tours make for a memorable afternoon in a historic neighborhood. 

Advertising
  • Things to do
  • Events & Festivals

Ready to make your relatinship Instagram official? You're going to need a photo for that, of course.

Lucky for your lovebirds, the Pumpkin Arch in the Seaport has been installed for the season, and this incredibly Instagrammable installation is worth checking out for free through November 3. 

What is a pumpkin arch exactly? Think of a balloon arch but with decorative pumpkins instead of balloons, plus some fall foliage and vines to add to the autumnal energy.

Advertising
  • Things to do

In our humble option, fall’s the best time to take your date on a hike. There’s just something about the crisp air, the changing foliage and the apple cider doughnuts you pack as a romantic surprise to share at the summit. Check out some of our favorite hikes in the New York City area, many of which are easily accessible via train or bus for a day trip.  

Advertising

Combat cold autumn nights by warming up next to a brick pizza oven. At Pizza School (pizzaschool.com), you can sign up for a couple’s pizza-making class with your sweetheart. You’ll learn how to master the perfect crust and sauce, including how to properly place toppings, while getting creative (and a little messy). Note: In-person tickets are $325 for couples, and virtual options are available for an at-home date night.

Advertising
  • Things to do

The Great Jack O’Lantern Blaze is one of the best things to do in the fall in the New York area. Admire the beauty of your S.O. in the crisp air with nothing but the romantic glow of over 7,000 jack o’lanterns to light their face. Ogling your “honeybear” and all the pretty gourds isn’t the only draw; you can snuggle up with some hot cider or hot chocolate and take advantage of the stargazing opportunities inside the Pumpkin Planetarium.

  • Things to do
  • Walks and tours

No other activity screams, “hold me,” as much as the spooky ghost tours offered in New York during the Halloween season. Take a candlelit stroll through haunted venues such as the Merchant’s House Museum (merchantshouse.org), or explore 'hoods bursting with paranormal activity (i.e. Brooklyn Heights and Astoria) with the folks behind Boroughs of the Dead (boroughsofthedead.com). Your date will be latched onto you so tight, your circulation may suffer—but, like, in a sexy way.

Advertising
  • Comedy
  • Stand-up
Get tickets to the New York Comedy Festival
Get tickets to the New York Comedy Festival

The best way to entertain a date is to make them laugh, right? One of the biggest fall events in Gotham—the New York Comedy Festival—brings some of the best comedians to popular clubs such as the Beacon Theatre and the Apollo Theater. See stand-up legends including Margaret Cho, Nicole Byer and Dave Attell kill it in the spotlight.

  • Beer bars
  • Greenpoint

Out of all the beer gardens and beer halls in New York, Spritzenhaus offers a romantic ambience, especially during the colder months (the haunt is craftily decorated with white twinkle lights and pine).

Rather than plop your keisters at one of the long, wooden picnic tables, opt for more intimate seating by the bar. You and your date can snack on hearty traditional German processions such as pretzels and brats and sip spiked cider, mulled wine or a stein filled to the brim with suds.

Looking for more fun ideas?

Recommended
    You may also like
    You may also like
    Advertising