The players
Nicollette Barsamian, 25, and Jon Headlee, 30, Forest Hills, Queens
This pair brings a whole new edge to the meet-cute: Nicollette Barsamian’s friends left her in Jon Headlee’s arms outside of the party Dungeon X on Delancey Street, with a cagey, “You’re safe, right?” The two spent the night playing in the dungeon together until Barsamian choked a third person a bit too hard for their taste. (“She kind of has She-Hulk–like strength,” says Headlee.) Headlee, who is straight, has been experimenting with open relationships since he found the fetish communities of Richmond at age 21, and Barsamian, who is bisexual, has only been poly since she got involved with BDSM (and Headlee) last March. While Headlee still seeks emotional (not physical) connections with others, Barsamian considers herself “polyfuckorous”—that is, she has sex, but not emotional interactions, outside of her relationship with Headlee. And as far as managing judgment from peers, both are unconcerned and happy about how exciting their lives are in comparison to their contemporaries. “My first girlfriend ended up just marrying a cop and having kids,” says Headlee. “There’s an article about me in Hustler.”