The 9 best cookie delivery services in NYC

Known for its completely customizable cookies, Eleni’s delivers adorable and super delicious sugar cookies with next-level decorations. Though its Chelsea location shuttered, you can still order everything from traditional birthday and holiday treats to monograms, photos and even color-your-own cookies with edible markers. 

Order online

There’s no excuse why you shouldn’t have Christina Tosi’s cult classic cookies in your pantry—they’re available for shipping nationwide. Cookie flavors include peppermint pretzel snap,
cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow, and chocolate confetti. Newbies should opt for the compost, a sweet and salty confection loaded with pretzels, potato chips, graham crackers and other goodies—it’s one of the amazingly delicious treats that Milk Bar is known for.

Order online

At Levain, the cookies are so huge, they might as well be lunch. The massive mounds stay underdone in the middle, making them a boon to cookie-dough lovers. Don’t miss the lush, brownie-like double-chocolate number, or order a few different flavors for delivery in sets of four, eight, and a full dozen. And no need to worry about availability across the five boroughs—this renowned bakery ships around the United States.

This shrine to collegiate munchies—first launched at the University of Pennsylvania—churns out highly addictive cookies in classic flavors like chocolate chunk, Classic with M&Ms, and snickerdoodle for delivery from midmorning through the wee hours of late night. (Read: insomnia.) With 16 locations across the city, you can order anywhere from six to 300 rounds. Cakes and sides like buttercream or cream cheese icing, as well as a ‘wiches, ice cream-stuffed cookie sandwiches, are also available. 

Order online

This uber indulgent shop located on LaGuardia Place is dedicated entirely to safe-to-eat cookie dough. Ask for one, two, or three scoops of traditional chocolate chip and sugar cookie in a cup or cone, or opt for one of the more whimsical flavors like cake batter, dunkadoo or peanut butter snickerdoodle. Most menu options will likely lead you to a sugar crash, but it maybe all that decadence is worth it. 

Order online

The brainchild of two childhood friends living in Astoria, Chip City has been dishing out over 40 different flavors of cookies since 2017. The menu changes daily, with rotating flavors including red velvet hot chocolate, white chocolate macadamia, blueberry cheesecake, and Nutella sea salt. Those looking to gift should opt for one of the many baking bundles on offer. 

Order online

If there’s one good thing that came out of the pandemic, it’s Best Damn Cookies, proprietor Dave Dreifus’s expertly crafted confections available both online and at Essex Street Market. With Dreifus having Michelin street cred, working in top kitchens including SingleThread and The French Laundry, these cookies are no joke. We recommend starting with The OG, an elevated take on the classic chocolate chip cookie, which took Dreifus an entire two months of trial and error to get it right.

Order online

This custom cake shop also specializes in hulking half-pound cookies with crinkly edges and soft centers in flavors like red velvet, triple chocolate spice, and oatmeal raisin. Some varieties are even packed with fillings like Nutella and Reese's Pieces. (A gluten-free variety pack is also on offer!) Order an assorted pack to split with friends and try them all.

Order online

This wildly popular cookie brand built its following online before setting up shop in Hell's Kitchen. Sweet tooths can choose from cookies in funky flavors like maple bacon, vegan cotton candy, and the aptly-named cereal killer studded with Fruity Pebbles, Froot Loops, cornflakes and marshmallow cream.

Order online