Katonah Pizza & Pasta

A stalwart slice shop in Van Cortlandt Park, this neighborhood go-to is kitted out with neon lettering in the windows and wooden booths in the dining room, and serves pasta, calzone, burgers and, of course, pies with toppings ranging from Philly-style cheesesteak and pineapple-ham to marsala-spiked mushroom and buffalo chicken.