1. The Flour Shop
For all-things colorful and whimiscal, The Flour Shop is the obvious choice. Delight your little mermaids and unicorn lovers with the Explosion Cake ($150)—quite literally a rainbow surprise with every bite. The mutlicolor layers are sweetened with cream cheese frosting and sprinkles that pour out with each cut. Make sure you have a large serving plate at the ready. Though gorgeous, this treat is bound to get very messy, very quickly (but we promise it's worth it). Custom orders are also available if you're looking to experiment. SoHo (flourshop.com).