If you’re planning a visit to Miami’s Coconut Grove, you’re likely already privy to the many qualities that make the area unique and, yes, worth sacrificing the beach for. This leafy swath of bayfront just south of the city core has a chic bohemian vibe, and Mayfair House Hotel & Garden perfectly encapsulates the neighborhood’s essence.
The hotel opened in 1984 with an eye-catching organic design by the architect and sculptor Kenneth Treister. In 2022, it reopened following a meticulous renovation by New York-based studio Goodrich. Its best feature—the central atrium where lush greenery cascades into a network of flowing pools and fountains—remains intact. The spacious rooms, which nearly all boast their own private garden balconies, have been updated in moody jewel tones with plush white bedding and vintage accents.
Despite all the greenery in and surrounding the hotel, Mayfair House doesn’t bill itself as a “wellness” or “eco” hotel. You won’t find a spa on property, though you can upgrade your stay with a soaking menu designed to maximize your personal clawfooted tub. And should you wish to venture into nature, the hotel is equipped with free bikes for guests to explore the Grove’s verdant parks and waterfront trails. It’s also pet and family-friendly (though the romantic vibe here makes it feel more like a couples’ retreat.)
You’re choosing Mayfair House for the vibes: the ornate light fixtures, elaborate tilework and intricate tropical details laced throughout the property that whisper “luxe” rather than shout it. You’re definitely spending a solid chunk of your time up at the rooftop pool, with its comfy loungers, the Caribbean-inspired Sipsip Rum Bar and views of Biscayne Bay. You’re coming to Mayfair House to chill out and experience a mellower slice of Miami, where shady sidewalks are lined with funky shops and cafes. But you’re also coming here to eat.
On the ground floor you’ll find Mayfair Grill and Fountain Lounge, both helmed by award-winning local chef Giorgio Rapicavoli. The former highlights food-fired cooking, with exceptional dishes like a starter of clams in a white bean and chorizo dashi broth, a brief pasta section and a well-rounded menu of grilled proteins from the sea and land. Tucked in the atrium, the Fountain Lounge has its own menu of tapas-style plates—but the “Classic Miami” drinks are the main event here, like the surprisingly balanced Coconut Grove martini made with salted coconut water brine and orange bitters. You will want to kick back here and stay a while.
Neighborhood
Home to festivals and book shops, marinas and sailing clubs, independent restaurants and architectural gems, Coconut Grove is a free-spirited, historic enclave in Miami and a unique, low-key alternative to the flashy scene in South Beach. It’s a bit self-contained, meaning you’ll have to commute to other popular areas in Miami, like Brickell, Downtown and Wynwood, but there’s still plenty to explore, including a number of cultural institutions and amazing dining options.
Nearby
El Bagel for the best bagels and breakfast sandwiches in Miami. This is the second outpost of the Miami favorite and is located just across the street from the Mayfair lobby.
Vizcaya Museum & Gardens for a tour of the storied mansion, its manicured lawns and slowly eroding waterfront structures, which make for some of the most iconic photo backdrops anywhere in Miami.
Ariete for the pinnacle of Miami Michelin-starred dining. Executive chef and owner Michael Beltran (who has since spawned numerous restaurants as part of his Ariete Hospitality Group) merges old Latin tradition, South Florida ingredients and high-level French technique at this dimly lit gem.
Time Out tip
Admit it: You still kind of want to go to the beach. (Come on, you’re in Miami!) If so, skip South Beach and head to Key Biscayne. The beautiful Crandon Beach is closer—15 to 20 minutes from Mayfair House by car—with plenty of parking, rentable loungers and a much more relaxed atmosphere.