The best baseball movies of all time

Director: John Hancock

Cast: Robert De Niro, Michael Moriarty, Vincent Gardenia

Best line: "Everybody'd be nice to you if they knew you were dying." "Everybody knows everybody is dying; that's why people are as good as they are."

Robert De Niro’s shy, sensitive, baseball catcher succumbs to terminal Hodgkin’s Disease in this touching melodrama. The film was commercial and critical home run at the time of its release, and though the baseball scenes themselves are secondary and none too convincing, De Niro nails the sentimental tearjerker stuff.

Director: Anna Boden, Ryan Fleck

Cast: Algenis Perez Soto, Jose Rijo, Walki Cuevas

Best line: "No cervezas in the casa. No chicas in the bedroom."

For every Adrián Beltré success story (he was signed to the Dodgers at age 15 and transitioned well), there are a dozen Dominican players like the fictional composite Miguel “Sugar” Santos—a talented pitcher hacking it out in the U.S. minor leagues. Filmmakers Ryan Fleck and Anna Boden lay on the culture clashes beautifully, but it’s the dangling promise of the American Dream that really gets this movie hitting fly balls over the fence.

Director: George Abbott, Stanley Donen

Cast: Tab Hunter, Gwen Verdon, Ray Walston

Best line: "Whatever Lola wants, Lola gets. And little man, little Lola wants you."

It’s a humorous retelling of the Faust story, translated to the unlikely setting of 1950s baseball. Lifelong Washington Senators fan Joe Boyd sells his soul to the Devil—in the guise of the unctuous Mr. Applegate—in exchange for becoming the star player his team badly needs. Though lumbered with too much plot, the musical also has scintillating choreography by Bob Fosse and an equally brilliant score by Richard Adler and Jerry Ross (a songwriting team also responsible for the marvelous The Pajama Game).

Director: David Ward

Cast: Tom Berenger, Charlie Sheen, Corbin Bernsen

Best line: "Jesus, I like him very much, but he no help with curveball."

New ex-showgirl owner of the Cleveland Indians, desperate to relocate the team to sunny Florida and herself to an exotic condo, gathers together a bunch of players so awful that their failure will justify the move. Like so much of the film it's a silly but not too silly proposition; and what redeems it is that the action sequences are superbly filmed, climaxing with Sheen's bullish entry into the arena at make-or-break time, the crowd singing "Wild Thing" in clamoring unison.

Director: Barry Levinson

Cast: Robert Redford, Robert Duvall, Glenn Close

Best line: "People don't start playing ball at your age, they retire!"

This is the moment when baseball becomes golden-hued pageantry onscreen, the diamond dappled with sunbeams and the promise of redemption. Even if the film changed the ending of Bernard Malamud’s classic novel, there’s no doubting the genius of cinematographer Caleb Deschanel (Zooey’s dad) and effortless star Robert Redford as a minor league player who gets an elusive second chance at glory 20 years later.

Director: Penny Marshall

Cast: Tom Hanks, Geena Davis, Lori Petty

Best line: "There's no crying in baseball!"

Penny Marshall’s funny and moving dramedy about a WWII-era women’s ball team has an A-list roster (Hanks, Davis, Madonna), some stellar pinch hitters (hey, Rosie O’Donnell) and memorable one-liners that’ll have you choking on your chewing tobacco. It's also a touching testament to a time when women showed that they could, and then did, do it all—in miniskirts, no less.

Director: David M. Evans

Cast: Tom Guiry, Mike Vitar, Patrick Renna

Best line: "Oh! The Great Bambino, of course. I thought you said the great... Bambi."

There needs to be room on this list for some lighthearted fun—a movie that makes kids want to play ball and makes adults reminisce about summertime (while also maybe rolling their eyes a bit). This scrappy group live to play, but must alter their diamond-shaped reality when faced with the perennial childhood ordeal of retrieving their ball from a neighbor's yard. Their dilemma is highlighted by the killer mutt who lives on the other side of the fence, and distractions include the pretty pool lifeguard, rival rag-tags and the making of s'mores.

Director: Phil Alden Robinson

Cast: Kevin Costner, James Earl Jones, Ray Liotta

Best line: "If you build it, he will come."

Kevin Costner had already strutted his stuff once in Bull Durham, but Phil Alden Robinson’s syrupy-sentimental tale of a man building a playing field in his backyard proved that the star was Hall of Fame material. Here, baseball isn’t just a game; it’s a chance for fathers, sons and even dead legends to have one last crack at redemption.

Director: John Sayles

Cast: John Cusack, Clifton James, Michael Lerner

Best line: "When the bat meets that ball and you feel that ball just give, you know it's going to go a long way. Damn, if you don't feel like you're going to live forever."

This real-life scenario—about the infamous Chicago “Black Sox,” who threw the 1919 World Series—makes Sayles' directorial stridency go down in riveting fashion, as does a dynamite cast (whose athleticism and commitment blesses the film’s baseball scenes with true authenticity) led by John Cusack. But it’s the film’s mournful coda that lingers longest in the mind, reminding us of the redemptive capacity that sport can allow and that, at the end of the day, it is the fans, not the headlines, who decide whether or not the myth is ultimately to be held distinct from the man.

Director: Sam Wood

Cast: Gary Cooper, Teresa Wright, Babe Ruth

Best line: "He lives for his job. He gets a lot of fun out of it. And fifty million other people get a lot of fun out of him, watching him do something better than anybody else ever did it before."

Fans were still mourning the death of legendary pinstriper Lou Gehrig when Sam Wood’s film about the first baseman hit screens, barely a year after his passing. This tip of the cap was the perfect salve to their grief. Gary Cooper’s “luckiest man on the face of the earth” speech captures the dignity, grace and resolve of one of the game’s true MVPs.

Director: Michael Ritchie

Cast: Walter Matthau, Tatum O'Neal, Vic Morrow

Best line: "Those Yankees are real turds."

A warm, inclusive and tender-hearted film that just happens to be about a drunken, last chance, shyster coach (Matthau), a worldly pre-teen female pitcher (O’Neal) saving up for a boob-job and a sex-obsessed adolescent loan-shark (future Watchmen star Jackie Earl Haley) all batting for a team sponsored by a bail bonds company. It’s an utterly charming essay on the corrosiveness inherent in competitive sport, and the only real bad news came in the form of a couple of reductive sequels and a largely woeful 2005 remake starring the once goof-proof Billy Bob Thornton.

Director: Ron Shelton

Cast: Kevin Costner, Susan Sarandon, Tim Robbins

Best line: "I've tried 'em all, I really have, and the only church that truly feeds the soul, day in day out, is the church of baseball."

Director Shelton has dabbled in boxing (Play it to the Bone), basketball (White Men Can’t Jump) and golf (Tin Cup), but will, it seems, always be at his best in the church of baseball. His (and the sport's) finest comedy celebrates baseball in ways that are often overlooked: the long stretches of bum luck, the wispiness of job security, the transient thrill of a valiant at-bat. A former minor league ballplayer himself, Shelton knows all the bases and casts an insider’s eye over the fates of an undisciplined young pitcher (Robbins) who's the future of the game, a fading journeyman clutching to memories of a 21-day stint in "the Show" (Costner at the height of his likability) and the ball-obsessed groupie (Sarandon) from whom they both learn a few valuable life lessons. The three of them make up a triangle of need and resentment, undergirding a movie of rare grace. The script might be a tad overwritten, but any baseball film that trades in quantum physics, William Blake and quadraphonic Blaupunkts is fine by us.